SOLVED: Bon Ami Vs. Bar Keepers Friend: Insights

With sanitation greatly influencing the quality of life, keeping the house clean is one of the tasks that require special attention from modern homeowners. Nowadays, a wide range of cleaning products exist but regarding performance, two names stand out from the rest: Bon Ami and Bar Keepers Friend. Capable of giving a good account of themselves in plenty of scenarios, both products seldom let people down. That being said, with different homeowners having different preferences, everyone is at odds about Bon Ami Vs. Bar Keepers Friend.

A Summary Of The Products

Mua Bar Keepers Friend Powdered Cleanser 12-Ounces (1-Pack) (Packaging May Vary) trên Amazon Mỹ chính hãng 2021 | Fado

Have a hard time making up your mind between Bon Ami and Bar Keepers Friend? In that case, you have come to the right place. This article is going to tell you all the details about these cleaning products so you could make a wise decision.

Breakdowns Of Bon Ami And Bar Keepers Friend

Bon Ami 

As a natural cleanser, Bon Ami relies on simple ingredients (baking soda, limestone, …) instead of harsh chemicals which make it environmentally friendly. In addition to that, Bon Ami is a hypoallergenic product that contains no perfumes, dyes and so on in its formula. Hence, the odds of Bon Ami provoking allergic reaction tend to be low for most of the time. Needless to say,  Bon Ami earns a shower of praises from homeowners who have to deal with allergies on occasions.

Bar Keepers Friend

While the formula changes between lines of products, Bar Keepers Friend always makes extensive use of Oxalic acid. Because of that, Bar Keepers Friend excels at getting rid of rust, mineral deposits, … on quite a few surfaces. Besides that, Bar Keepers Friend is available in various forms too and that is a big plus once it comes to storage. Assuming that people keep Bar Keepers Friend in a dry place, it would remain usable for years to come.

A Characteristic Comparison Of The Products 


The formula of Bon Ami makes it a bit abrasive but its level of abrasiveness is below that of other cleaning products on the market. On the other hand, owing to the presence of chemicals in its composition, Bar Keepers Friend is mildly abrasive. As a result, homeowners may use whatever cleaning product that they want for typical cleaning. However, to clean dedicated surfaces, a lot of people agree that Bon Ami is the winner in Bon Ami Vs. Bar Keepers Friend.

Rust Removal

Overall, Bon Ami could remove rust when a need arises but in terms of efficiency and effectiveness, Bar Keepers Friend is the superior cleaning product. With Bar Keepers Friend, homeowners don’t have to do much to deal with rust and restore the original appearance of surfaces. You need something that would help you take care of rust in the interior of your house? Then it’s strongly recommended that you stock up on Bar Keepers Friend.


For your information, Bon Ami works best on soft surfaces whereas Bar Keepers Friend is oriented toward hard ones. Still, it’s worth pointing out that you could use both cleaning products interchangeably on a multitude of surfaces.


Bon Ami as well as Bar Keepers Friend reach the market in a number of forms: powder, spray, etc. Nonetheless, regarding variety, Bar Keepers Friend is the one that comes out on top in Bon Ami Vs. Bar Keepers Friend. Usually, people should be able to pick up any form of Bar Keepers Friend that they desire by paying a visit to the local home improvement store. That is advantageous for those who want to use different forms of a cleaning product for different cleaning tasks.


You don’t have to recalculate your spending plan to squeeze in cleaning products such as Bon Ami and Bar Keepers Friend. That being said, on average, Bar Keepers Friend costs a bit more than Bon Ami and that affects the shopping budget in the long run. If you happen to have money to spend, Bar Keepers Friend is not a bad choice for cleaning product. Conversely, if you wish to cut down expenses to save a couple of bucks, it’s widely advised that you go for  Bon Ami.

Choosing Between Bon Ami And Bar Keepers Friend: Suggestions 

Homeowners don’t have a consensus about Bon Ami vs. Bar Keepers Friend. However, in the case that you like to make the right call, you may want to check out these tips and tricks.

  • Give the surfaces some thought: To get the best result, it’s a good idea to take surfaces into account while looking for cleaning products. If you need to wash soft surfaces that cannot handle too much abrasiveness, stick to Bon Ami. On the flip side, if surfaces that require cleaning happen to be hard, you should select Bar Keepers Friend as your main cleaning product.
  • Consider the cost of products: Though the expense for cleaning products seems insignificant at first glance, it adds up over time. That means if you have to work on a tight wallet, you must keep cost in mind as you assess Bon Ami and Bar Keepers Friend. In general, to save money for more pressing needs, you have to think about using Bon Ami.
  • Use storage conditions as reference: The way you store your cleaning product influences its performance. That is why it’s important to include storage in the list of considerations. That would let you decide which form of product suits you most.


33 Shades of Green: Bon Ami Cleaning Product Giveaway

Do Bon Ami and Bar Keepers Friend ever expire?

The manufacturers of Bon Ami and Bar Keepers Friend claim that with proper storage, the shelf life of their products is indefinite. Because of that, you don’t have to worry about your cleaning products going bad as time passes by. Nonetheless, you still have to check out the storage condition every now and then. The last thing you want to see is your stock of cleaning products becoming unusable due to oversights.

Could I mix Bon Ami and Bar Keepers Friend?

It’s unwise to mix cleaning products that feature different formulas unless you know exactly what would occur. To avoid mixing the products by mistake, you need to refrain from using old product containers.

Are Bon Ami and Bar Keepers Friend septic safe?

Both cleaning products don’t cause any trouble for the septic system of modern residences. Therefore, regardless of which product you use, you can rest assured knowing that your septic system is safe.

Bar Keepers Friend Cleansers - YouTube


Leave a Comment